KP Astrology vs Vedic Astrology

KP rules are simple and logical and accurate. Vedic has a lot of rules and books to get prediction and not so precise predictions.

Wed Sep 23, 2020

KP Astrology versus Vedic Astrology

"KP rules are simple and logical and accurate. Vedic has a lot of rules and books to get prediction and not so precise predictions.

KP Astrology versus Vedic Astrology

Krishnamurti Padhdhati (KP) Follows the Placidus system for the distribution of cusps. Vedic follows Sripat Paddhati.

Cusps start at the end of the previous bhava (sort of a boundary line or a compound wall) in KP. Vedic chooses midpoint.

KP Aspects are from degree to degree. Vedic astrology follows cusp to cusp Aspects.

Duration of Year of 365.25 days in KP but Vedic takes it as 360.

KP rules are simple and logical and accurate. Vedic has a lot of rules and books to get prediction and not so precise predictions.

KP is Logical and precise. Vedic has lost the accuracy of predictions because of missed data.

Ayanamsa plays a major role in giving accurate predictions. KP has its own single ayanamsa. Vedic has lots of ayanamsas provided by so many astrologers. Each Ayanamsa gives different values to Planets and Cusps.

One can learn KP in very few months but one cannot learn full Vedic astrology in his life.

Vedic cannot pinpoint the time of fructification but KP can tell the exact time of fructification of the event.

KP treats the 9th Cusp as the House of Father and 10th Cusp for social status/career but Vedic takes 10th Cusp for Father/social status/career.

KP follows the rules given by sage Parashar for Vimshottari Dasha/Moon. KP has divided each planet and cusp Sign (Dasha) into Bhukti, Bhukti into Antar, and Antar into Sukshuma in the same ratio as done by sage Parashar in Vimshottari Dasha. It gives accurate results but Vedic does not do so.

Vedic follows Navamsa of Moon Sign only but KP follows navamsa of Nakshatra of each Planet and Cusp.

KP introduced a new fast-moving point which can differentiate between two early births as twins, it is known as Fortuna.

What is KP astrology?

KP astrology is essentially the investigation of Stellar Astrology in which we study Nakshatras or Stars and dependent on these boundaries, foresee an occasion in one's life.

There are various sorts of Astrology characterized around the world. KP framework is one of them. It is otherwise called "KP astrology". It is a best method to anticipate an occasion precisely. It is celebrated among stargazers because of its "Simple to Apply and Easy to Understand" idea. It is perhaps the most straightforward strategy in Hindu Astrology.

What Is KP Astrology, and what is the difference between Vedic and KP Astrology?

Besides classical astrology, I have personally invested a few decades in experimenting with KP and off late with the CIL system and I can deliberate upon prose and cones of each but this is not the right place. Without going into details, I would like to state that it depends upon who is asking the question?

Is it from the perspective of a person who wants to avail guidance from the horoscope or
is it from the perspective of a learner?

If this is with the perspective to take benefit of astrology, the system followed by the astrologer would not make much of a difference to the guidance seeker. The horoscope charted accurately and provide details correctly should be good enough. It is, ultimately the knowledge, experience, and wisdom of the astrologer who analyzes and interprets it will make all the difference.

Those who try to belittle the classical system ignore the fact that the prime precepts of KP rest upon the classical Nakshatra (Stellar) concept of ecliptic division (generally known only in the form of the Vimsottari Dasha system). Such an attitude is nothing more than the tantrums of a crying kid who is kicking and bruising the mother who has lifted it in her arms.

If it is from the perspective of a learner, KP would seem to be easier. The tedious part of finding sub and sub-sub details of each cusp and each planet is taken care of by the computer software. With KP, you may feel comfortable as you don’t need to remember innumerable yogas and doshas and you don’t have to swim across an ocean of unknown waters of divisional charts..!!

However, this would only be true as long as you follow tutorials of a KP master who is offering tuition to learners. It seems very simple and accurate as being worked through illustrations and in a postmortem manner. Ask anyone experimenting with KP about the complications and confusions one faces while predicting future events. The elimination process of effective signification is not as easy as it is shown. Predication through KP is equally fallible as it could be following any other method of astrology.

I wonder, if KP was most scientific and accurate, why did it spare scope for further microscopic methods like Cuspal Interlinks (CIL) based on Sub-Sub level? If we keep going deeper, no wonder, soon there will be claims of innovative systems working on even SUB-Sub-Sub level. The comfort of calculation through a computer has created this avenue. If a derivative system is accurate, it should become exclusive and there should not be any need for the furtherance of the same logic.

The essential idea of Astrology can be perceived by methods for standard practice and study. KP astrology isn't altogether different from Vedic astrology. The idea of KP framework or KP astrology has been gotten from Vedic astrology just as Western Astrology. These frameworks put stock in 12 Zodiac Signs, basically characterized around the world, henceforth KP astrology additionally doesn't deny this idea. Prior to continuing towards the standards of KP astrology.

What is Vedic astrology?

Vedic astrology is an antiquated Indian Science that clarifies Planetary Motions and Positions concerning Time and their Effects on Humans and Other Entities on Earth. Vedic astrology can be followed Thousands of years back. Early Vedic astrology was just founded on the development of Planets with Respect to Stars, yet later on, it's begun including Zodiac Signs too.

As indicated by Vedas Astrology there are 27 + 1 Constellations comprising 12 Zodiac Signs, 9 Planets, and 12 Houses. With each House and Plant speaking to some part of Human Life. Contingent upon when a Person is Born, the 12 Signs are dispersed among the 12 Houses and 9 Planets are put in Various Houses of Kundalis.

This visual portrayal of the depiction of the Signs and Planets is known as a Kundali/Horoscope Chart.

Vedic astrology is only deciphering the significance of these courses of action as it applies to Humans and Other Entities.

Difference between KP and Vedic astrology?

These are some differences between Vedic astrology and KP astrology. At the point when you Learn Astrology, you can be more clear about these distinctions.

• In Vedic astrology, the expectations appear to be the equivalent for individuals brought into the world with the same Lagna/Rasi. However, in reality, they don't have similar character characteristics.

• Vedic astrology is utilized to anticipate the future as per the difference in houses, while KP astrology predicts future occasions through cups (the interfacing hubs of two houses).

• KP astrology offers significance to the Stars or Nakshatras or Constellation divisions of the Zodiac and that fills the ideal need for exactness.

• They are additionally separated into 9 divisions and named 'SUBS'. These are not equivalent in Vedic astrology, yet they are equivalent on account of KP astrology.

• KP astrology utilizes K.P. Ayanamsa rather than Lahiri Ayanamshas which is by and large utilized in the Vedic System. These two vary by 6 minutes.

• According to KP astrology, the planets in their Dasha give results according to their Nakshatra Lord rather than the planet itself.

My Conclusion

Independent of contrasts in these two kinds of crystal gazing, they are for the most part used to foresee the nature, the character, or the occasions that may happen in the life of an individual. It is prescribed to think about celestial standards during urgent occasions of life to keep setbacks from occurring and to carry on with a quiet life.

What is the significance of KP Astrology?

First, there is no Vedic astrology specifically. Entire astrology is Vedic because it is from the Vedic age.

Yes, to understand, one can understand Parashari astrology by Sage Parashar, Jaimini Sutram by Sage Jamini, though I read in a book that Jaimini Sutram is also Parashari.

Then there is Samhita known in north India, known as Nadi in south India.

There are many Nadis.

Krishnamurthy Paddhatti propounded by Late Mr. K S Krishnamurthy is an extension of Nakshatra Nadi where the nakshatra is divided into nine parts unequally as per the ratio of the planetary dasa in vimshotri dasa system. The house division is also unequal. The lord of the ninth division of nakshtra is given utmost weightage to judge the natal and question chart.

Further research has been done and many other theories like cuspal interlinks, four step theory, theory of short predictions, more research is done on ruling planets, etc.

Is KP Astrology an easy system?

KP astrology is an easy system that is also accurate.

In simple language, KP astrology is easy to apply and anyone can predict anything that is related to their day-to-day life like job, weather, and health, etc.

In short; KP astrology is an excellent system for everyone who is new in astrology or just wants to predict few things.

Is KP Astrology entirely different from Vedic Astrology?

KP Astrology is just an extension of Vedic Astrology. The additional principles that are proposed as part of KP (and some that are removed) will help to provide more accurate predictions.

KP Astrology is a stellar system. It makes extensive use of stars which do not play any role in Vedic astrology. (Note: There are many stellar extensions of Vedic astrology; KP is just one of them.)

In order to aid accurate predictions, additional KP principles revolve around concepts like SUB LORD and RULING PLANETS discovered by Sri Krishnamurti.

Is Vedic Astrology more accurate than KP Astrology?

Vedic astrology depends upon signs. But KP ASTROLOGY depends upon stars and their sub-lords. To be Frank Vedic astrology laws or formulas are outdated and obsolete. KP formulas are very accurate and fruitful.

What are the specific differences between Vedic and KP Astrology?

1. KP astrology is based on the theories of Prof. Krishnamurthy whereas Vedic Jyotish is believed to be based on the theories & techniques given by Vedic muni Prashara and the Jyotish has its roots in Vedas, they say. There is no substantial proof given to such claims of Vedic Astrology.

2. In KP astrology the nakshatra Dasha gives the results indicated by the ruler of nakshatra in which the Dasha lord is placed whereas in Vedic Jyotish the nakshatra Dasha gives the results of the planets occupying the nakshatra of Dasha lord.

3. In KP astrology the results of Mahadasha depend on what they call SUB and it is nothing but a view of Antardasha whereas in Vedic Jyotish the results of Antardasha depend on Mahadasha.

4. In KP astrology bhava chalit is used whereas in In Vedic Jyotish chalit chakra is used.

5. In KP astrology this punney saham is also known as Fortuna is the same for day and night whereas in Vedic Jyotish the calculations of this puney saham are different for day and night.

6. In KP astrology mostly practical approach is used for the so-called analysis of a horoscope whereas in Vedic Jyotish certain guesswork and intuitive approaches are used to analyze a horoscope. Therefore, the results are not accurate in the Vedic system.

7. In KP astrology there is no guesswork involved for prediction by an astrologer whereas Vedic Jyotish gives vague knowledge and guidelines to an astrologer to create his own system of predictions.

What is KP Astrology?

Krishnamurthy Paddhati of Astrology is additionally one such framework that is utilized regularly to anticipate occasions later on with higher precision. It is otherwise called KP Astrology in short where KP clearly represents Krishnamurthy Paddhati. KP framework study was conceived by Shri K.S. Krishnamurti is considered perhaps the most acclaimed Astrologer ever.

What is Vedic Astrology?

Vedic Astrology is an antiquated Indian science that clarifies planetary movements and positions regarding time and their impact on people and different elements on earth. Vedic Astrology can be followed millennia back. Early Vedic Astrology was just founded on the development of planets concerning stars, yet later on, it began including zodiac signs also. As indicated by Vedic Astrology there are 27 groups of stars comprised of 12 zodiac signs, 9 planets, and 12 houses with each house and planet addressing some part of human existence. Contingent upon when an individual is conceived, the 12 signs are appropriated among the 12 houses and 9 planets are set in different houses. This visual portrayal of the depiction of the signs and planets is known as a horoscope diagram. Vedic Astrology is only deciphering the importance of these plans as it applies to people and different elements.

Which one is better?

KP Astrology and Vedic Astrology both utilize antiquated Astrology techniques and have their own significance. Vedic Astrology gives you the forecasts about your life by just utilizing the antiquated Hindu strategies yet KP Astrology Science is a procedure gotten from Ancient Hindu Astrology and Western Astrology Methods. In this way, Prediction about an Event in the Future can be determined all the more effectively and precisely based on the KP Astrology System.

Dissemination of Cusps is done according to the Placidus System in KP and Vedic follows Sripati Paddhati.

The beginning of the Cusp is taken as the Start point in KP and it is taken as the Midpoint in Vedic.

Perspectives are taken degree shrewd and they are material according to the circle of the individual planet in KP. Vedic Astrology follows cusp to cusp Aspects.

The span of the Year of 365.25 days however Vedic accepts it as 360 for simple computations.

Fewer principles however Vedic have heaps of rules and books to get exact forecasts.

Legitimate and Vedic have lost the exactness of forecasts in view of missed information.

Ayanamsha assumes a significant part in exactness KP has its own and single ayanamsa however Vedic has loads of ayanamsa gave by so many Astrologers. Each Ayanansha gives various qualities to Planets and Cusps.

Understandability One can learn KP in not many months yet one can not learn full Vedic Astrology in his life.

Exactness Vedic can not pinpoint the hour of fructification yet KP can tell the specific season of fructification of the occasion.

Place of Father KP regards the ninth Cusp as the House of Father and tenth Cusp for economic wellbeing/transporter yet Vedic takes the tenth Cusp for Father/societal position/transporter.

Fundamentals KP adheres to the guidelines given by sage Parashar for Vimshottari Dasha/Moon. KP has separated every planet and cusp Sign (Dasha) into Bhukti, Bhukti into Antar, and Antar into Pratyantar in a similar proportion as done by sage Parashar in Vimshottari Dasha. It gives more precision however Vedic doesn't follow so.

Navamsa Vedic follows Navamansha of Moon Sign just however KP follows navamsa of Nakshatra of every Planet and Cusp.

Fortuna KP presented another quick point that can separate between two early births as twins, it is known as Fortuna.

Is KP Method of Astrology Better than Vedic Astrology?

From the point of view of easy learning, KP is better. The whole study can be summarised into the following parts -

A. Cusp division as per sign lord-star lord-sub lord

B. Planet's position as per sign lord-star lord-sub lord

C. Significators as per star-lord and sub-lord

D. Combination for different life incidents

E. Ruling planets

A deep understanding of Vedic astrology is like the universe manifesting itself in all its glory. Detailed Vedic astrology cannot reveal accurate and minute predictions about a person.

There are so many things in Vedic astrology like divisional charts up to d-60, ashtakvarga, indu lagna, hora lagna, nadi jyotish, bhrigu secrets, bhrigu chakra, jaimini sutras, different yantras and their connection to your horoscope, different letters mantras to positively influence weak houses in the horoscope, different sensitive points in a horoscope, then different kind of chakras to predict. All these are extremely complicated to learn and practice. No one has really acquired the meaning of all these things. Hence, an accurate understanding is impossible.

So, given the opportunity, you should go for KP astrology as, in the long run, it will help you understand life's predictions accurately.

How does KP differ from Traditional Astrology?

Traditional Astrology:

1. There are 12 houses signifying different subjects of life.

2. All the 12 houses are of equal size.

3. Each house begins with the beginning of a sign and ends with the sign.

4. The whole house is important.

5. Each sign, therefore, occupies at least one house.

6. Each planet owns a house.

7. Every planet has attributions.

8. Every sign has attributions.

9. Sign: Rasi as a whole is considered.

10. Nakshatras have attributes. However, only Moon's nakshatra is considered and used significantly.

11. Nakshatras are broadly divided into 4 parts: Padas.

12. There is no further subdivision of nakshatra padas.

13. Various charts and tables other than birth (natal or horary) charts are used.

14. Various Varga charts

15. Manifestation of subjects of the house is evaluated in terms of planet placed in the house, status of the lord of that house, and planets aspecting the house and its lord.

16. Planet occupying the house is important for that house.

17. Condition of the planet ruling the sign of the house, e.g. Exaltation, Own sign, Debilitation, etc.

18. Aspect of the planet on the house and its lord have an influence on the house.

19. Presence of planets in the 2nd and 12th of a house under scrutiny can influence the house or the house lord.

20. There is nothing like Ruling Planets.

21. Badhakesha creates impediments.

22. Horary or Prashna Chart is used but there are no supporting elements like ruling planets or the Horary numbers.

23. There can be Vargottama Status for a planet.

KP Astrology:

1. 1. There are 12 houses signifying different subjects of life.

2. Houses are not of equal size. Placidus House division is used in charting horoscope.

3. Each house begins with the specific arc of the sign called cusps.

4. The cusp of a house is important.

5. Since the beginning of a house, the cusp, is important, it may happen that some signs may not be on the cusp of any house.

6. If the sign owned by a planet is not on the cusp, the planet may be deprived of ownership.

7. Every planet has attributions.

8. Every sign has attributions.

9. In addition Rashi, the Nakshatra is focused.

10. Nakshatra of every cusp and every planet plays an important role.

11. Every Nakshatra is divided into 9 parts in the proportion to the Vimshottari Dasa system. Each ruled by a planet called Sub Lord.

12. Sub is further divided into 9 parts and each is ruled by Sub-Sub lord.

13. No other chart but Bhava Chalit Birth chart is required.

14. No other chart except Birth or Horary Bhava Chalit Charts.

15. KP Astrology interprets bhava or house results primarily on the basis of the house cuspal sub lord and the sub lord's stellar significations.

16. Planet occupying the house can be important to that house only if it is in its own Nakshatra and if no planet is under the nakshatra ruled by it.

17. The status of a planet, e.g., Exaltation, Own Sign, Debilitation, etc., are not considered.

18. Aspects of the planet are not considered except for certain western aspects.

19. Mere presence of planets in 2nd and 12th have no significance unless they signify the house under scrutiny.

20. The concept of Ruling Planets is important in determining competence and elimination of significators.

21. Badhakesha is not directly important.

22. There is a concept of selection of a horary number from 1-249. This number is important if the native has no idea about the birth details.

23. The consideration of Nakshatra lord can be similar to Vargottama's concept of traditional astrology.

Krish Murali Eswar
Professor in Astrology, Vastu Sasthra, Kundalini Yoga and Kayakalpa Yoga

Powered By Spayee